Memorials to miners and past mining disasters dot the public spaces in rural parts of southern Illinois. This granite obelisk is in honor of mining near West Frankfort, which is in the heart of Illinois coal country, and close to several operating mines. In 1980, Illinois had 18,000 coal miners - now, the workforce is less than 4,000. Mining experts say new digging permits, new hires and new investment in Illinois coal signals a comeback, though it's unclear mining employment will reach former heights. (Photo by Shawn Allee)
America has a love-hate relationship
with coal. We burn coal to make half our
electricity, but we’re always fighting coal’s
air pollution. Some regulations decimated
the coal industry in one key state. Shawn
Allee reports miners there are caught
between a slow comeback and another round of
regulation:
Transcript
America has a love-hate relationship
with coal. We burn coal to make half our
electricity, but we’re always fighting coal’s
air pollution. Some regulations decimated
the coal industry in one key state. Shawn
Allee reports miners there are caught
between a slow comeback and another round of
regulation:
Coal was once king of the Southern Illinois economy, but no longer.
Nathan Threewitt lives in the area. He explains mining jobs evaporated.
Nathan Threewitt: “Eighteen years ago, give or take a couple, people went from
making a nice, upper-class living to nothing at all. Couldn’t find work, everybody
had to move.”
Shawn Allee: “Did you have that happen in your own family?”
Threewitt: “Yep. My dad’s got ten brothers and sisters. They went from, everybody
had clothes for school, everybody had food to eat, to, we don’t know how the hell it
was gonna happen.”
Even though Threewitt has a tough history with coal – he’s actually trying to get into the
industry.
In fact, I find him while he’s taking a break from a coal mining training class at Rend
Lake College.
I know at one time, classes like these had been canceled.
I track down instructor David Colombo to see what’s changed.
David Colombo: “This room is where I train miners for the most part.”
Shawn Allee: “What’s this?”
Colombo: “Ugh. This is a high voltage cable.”
Allee: “This is almost as thick as your arm.”
Colombo: “This isn’t the biggest of the bigs, either.”
Right now, only about four thousand Illinois miners need to be familiar with equipment
like this.
But Colombo gets calls from mining companies in the area who need trained workers.
So, his school’s growing to keep up.
Shawn Allee: “Why have faith that you’re going to need space for miners to be
trained?”
David Colombo: “With the mining permitting that’s going on, is the highest it’s been
in thirty years.”
Colombo: “Gentlemen in this afternoon’s class will start sinking a mine within the
next week or two. Right now it just employs ten people, but in a year from now, that
same mine’s probably going to employ a hundred and ten people.”
People use words like rebound and comeback when they describe the Illinois coal
industry.
“It was really the effect of Clean Air Act amendments of 1990.”
This is John Mead. He heads coal research at Southern Illinois University.
He says Illinois coal is blessed with high energy, but it’s cursed with sulfur that caused
acid rain and lung disease. The amendments aimed to cut that.
“Most utilities were able to switch to lower-sulfur coal, and that’s just what they
did.”
In fact, utilities opened new mines out West where the coal has less sulfur.
As for an Illinois coal turn-around?
“Today, sulfur and other materials in the coal can be controlled pretty effectively
with technology.”
So, now Illinois coal can better compete with lower-sulpher coal.
But here’s the thing. There could be another pollution clamp-down in the works.
You know about global-warming, right? Well, carbon dioxide’s a big cause, and coal
produces carbon dioxide in spades.
Scientists say cutting coal emissions would be a quick way to cut carbon.
So, miners in Southern Illinois get mixed messages – the country wants their coal again,
but maybe not for long.
Miner-to-be Nathan Threewitt says he’s thought this through.
Nathan Threewitt: “Well, if anybody looked at the economics of it, it’s gonna go
back. Coal used to be fifteen dollars a ton, it’s now 65 dollars a ton. You’re gonna
have these coal companies with coal left in the ground, it used to not be worth it to
get the money out, now it’s worth it.”
Shawn Allee: “You like those odds.”
Threewitt: “Yeah, I do. I’m rolling the dice on it.”
Threewitt figures, he’s got time to build a career from coal, while America makes up its
mind just how clean it wants its coal-fired electricity.
For The Environment Report, I’m Shawn Allee.